The Problem of the Unfinished and the Shaping of the Canon of Finiteness in the Italian Renaissance

Fabio Tononi
NOVA University of Lisbon
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2113-0694

Volume 1, October 2021

Abstract
This essay addresses the debate on the unfinished in the visual arts from classical antiquity to the
Italian Renaissance and its aesthetic implications. It is divided into two sections. The first section
analyses the history of the unfinished, focusing on the debate that unfinished sculptures and
paintings have stirred among theorists, artists, and the public. This provides a definition, or a series
of definitions, of the notion of the unfinished and enables us to recognise the formation of what I
call the canon of finiteness in visual works of art. In this regard, based on historical sources, I propose
that the aesthetic of finiteness can be divided into three categories: ‘finished’, ‘unfinished’, and
‘over-finished’. Finally, the second section explores the various solutions that have been adopted in
dealing with unfinished works of art – namely, keeping them as such or completing them through
the efforts of other, later artists – in accordance with the canon of finiteness that gradually takes
shape.

Keywords
Canon of finiteness; Giorgio Vasari; Italian Renaissance; Titian; Unfinished

[pdf]

Bibliography

Alberti, Leon Battista, Il nuovo De pictura di Leon Battista Alberti / The New De pictura of Leon Battista Alberti, ed. by Rocco Sinisgalli (Rome: Kappa, 2006).

Aretino, Pietro, Lettere sull’arte di Pietro Aretino, ed. by Ettore Camesasca, 3 vols (Milan: Edizioni del Milione, 1957–1960).

Armenini, Giovanni Battista, De’ veri precetti della pittura (Ravenna: Francesco Tebaldini, 1587).

Attardi, Luisa, ‘Titian: The Annunciation’, in Titian, ed. by Giovanni C. F. Villa (Cinisello Balsamo and Milan: Silvana, 2013), pp. 228-231.

Beardsley, Monroe C., ‘On the Creation of Art’, in The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 23 (1965), 291-304.

Bellori, Giovan Pietro, Le vite de’ pittori, scvltori et architetti moderni (Rome: Per il success. al Mascardi, 1672).

Billi, Antonio, Il libro di Antonio Billi, ed. by Karl Frey (Berlin: Grote’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, 1892).

Blake McHam, Sarah, Pliny and the Artistic Culture of the Italian Renaissance: The Legacy of the Natural History (London and New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2013).

Bomford, David, ‘Old-Age Style and the Non Finito’, in Unfinished: Thoughts Left Visible, ed. by Kelly Baum et al. (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2016), pp. 48-55, 265-266.

Bonazza, Natalino, ‘Annunciation’, in Late Titian and the Sensuality of Painting, ed. by Sylvia Ferino-Pagden (Venice: Marsilio, 2008), pp. 257-259.

Borghini, Raffaello, Il riposo, ed. by Mario Rosci, 2 vols (Milan: Labor, 1967).

Boschini, Marco, Le ricche minere della pittura veneziana. Compendiosa informazione di Marco Boschini, non solo delle pitture publiche di Venezia, ma dell’isole ancora circonvicine (Venice: Francesco Nicolini, 1674).

Boschini, Marco, Carta del navegar pitoresco, ed. by Anna Pallucchini (Venice: Istituto per la collaborazione culturale, 1966).

Cicero, Letters to Friend, trans. and ed. by David R. Shackleton Bailey, 3 vols (Cambridge, MA, and London: Harvard University Press, 2001).

Condivi, Ascanio, Vita di Michelangelo Buonarroti, ed. by Giovanni Nencioni (Florence: Studio per edizioni scelte, 1998).

Dolce, Lodovico, Dialogo della pittura intitolato l’Aretino, in Trattati d’arte del Cinquecento: fra manierismo e Controriforma, ed. by Paola Barocchi, 3 vols (Bari: Laterza, 1960–1962).

Freedberg, David, ‘From Absorption to Judgment: Empathy in Aesthetic Response’, in Empathy: Epistemic Problems and Cultural-Historical Perspectives of a Cross-Disciplinary Concept, ed. by Vanessa Lux and Sigrid Weigel (New York: Palgrave MacMillan, 2017), pp. 139-180.

Freedberg, David, and Vittorio Gallese, ‘Motion, Emotion and Empathy in Aesthetic Experience’, in TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences, 11 (2007), 197-203.

Gallese, Vittorio, ‘Embodied Simulation. Its Bearing on Aesthetic Experience and the Dialogue between Neuroscience and the Humanities’, in Gestalt Theory, 41 (2019), 113-128.

Gentili, Augusto, Tiziano (Milan: 24 ore cultura, 2012).

Gordon, Dillian (ed.), The Fifteenth Century. Italian Paintings, 7 vols (London: National Gallery Company, 2003).

Hick, Darren Hudson, ‘When is a Work of Art Finished?’, in The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, 66 (2008), 67-76.

Hirst, Michael, ‘The Marble for Michelangelo’s Taddei Tondo’, in The Burlington Magazine, 1229 (2005), 548-549.

Hout, Nico van, The Unfinished Painting (Antwerp: Ludion, 2012).

Hout, Nico van, ‘The Unfinished and the Eye of the Beholder’, in Unfinished: Thoughts Left Visible, ed. by Kelly Baum et al. (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2016), pp. 56-61.

Joannides, Paul, Masaccio and Masolino: A Complete Catalogue (London and New York: Phaidon, 1993).

Leonardo da Vinci, Trattato della pittura, ed. by Ettore Camesasca (Vicenza: Neri Pozza, 2000).

Livingston, Paisley, Art and Intention: A Philosophical Study (Oxford: Clarendon, 2005).

Nepi Scirè, Giovanna, ‘La Pietà’, in Tiziano, ed. by Francesco Valcanover et al. (Venice: Marsilio, 1990), pp. 373-375.

Pino, Paolo, Dialogo di pittura, ed. by Rodolfo and Anna Pallucchini (Venice: Guarnati, 1946).

Pliny the Elder, Natural History, trans. by Harris Rackham, 10 vols (Cambridge, MA, and London: Harvard University Press and William Heinemann, 1938–1967).

Poliziano, Angelo, Angeli Politiani Miscellaneorum centuria prima (Chiusi, Siena: Luì, 1994).

Pope-Hennessy, John, Donatello Sculptor (New York: Abbeville Press, 1993).

Ridolfi, Carlo, Le maraviglie dell’arte: ovvero le vite degli illustri pittori veneti e dello stato descritte dal cav. Carlo Ridolfi, 2 vols (Padua: Cartallier, 1835).

Sansovino, Francesco, Dialogo di tutte le cose notabili e belle che sono in Venetia (Venice: Tipografia Emiliana, 1861).

Serlio, Sebastiano, Il secondo libro di prospettiva (Venice: Francesco Senese and Zuane Krugher Alemanno, 1566).

Sohm, Philip L., The Artist Grows Old: The Aging of Art and Artist in Italy, 1500–1800 (London and New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2007).

Titian, Le Lettere, ed. by Clemente Gandini (Pieve di Cadore: Magnifica Comunità di Cadore, 1977).

Tononi, Fabio, ‘Aesthetic Response to the Unfinished: Empathy, Imagination and Imitation Learning’, in Aisthesis: Pratiche, linguaggi e saperi dell’estetico, 13(1) (2020), 135-153.

Tononi, Fabio, ‘Intermediality and Immersion in Gaudenzio Ferrari’s Adoration of the Magi in Chapel V of the Sacred Mountain of Varallo’, in PsicoArt: Rivista di Arte e Psicologia, 10 (2020), 1-18.

Tononi, Fabio, ‘Andrea Mantegna and the Iconography of Mourners: Aby Warburg’s Notion of Pathosformeln and the Theory of Aesthetic Response’, in IKON: Journal of Iconographic Studies, 13 (2020), 79-94.

Tononi, Fabio, ‘The Aesthetics of Freud: Movement, Embodiment and Imagination’, in Reti, saperi, linguaggi: Italian Journal of Cognitive Sciences, 1 (2021), 125-154.

Varchi, Benedetto, Orazione funerale di Messer Benedetto Varchi fatta, e recitata da lui pubblicamente nell’essequie di Michelagnolo Buonarroti in Firenze nella chiesa di San Lorenzo, ed. by Charles Davis (Florence: Giunti, 2008).

Vasari, Giorgio, Lives of the Most Eminent Painters, Sculptors and Architects, trans. by Gaston du C. de Vere, 10 vols (London: Macmillan and The Medici Society, 1912–1915).

Vasari, Giorgio, Vasari on Technique, trans. by Louisa S. Maclehose, ed. by Gerard B. Brown (New York: Dover, 1960).

Vasari, Giorgio, Le vite de’ più eccellenti pittori scultori e architettori: nelle redazioni del 1550 e 1568, ed. by Rosanna Bettarini and Paola Barocchi, 6 vols (Florence: Sansoni, 1966).

Wethey, Harold E., The Paintings of Titian: Complete Edition, 3 vols (London: Phaidon, 1969).

Wootton, Will, Ben Russell and Peter Rockwell, ‘Stoneworking Techniques and Processes’, in The Art of Making in Antiquity: Stoneworking in the Roman World (2013), 1-35. <http://www.artofmaking.ac.uk/content/essays/3-stoneworking-techniques-and-processes-w-wootton-b-russell-p-rockwell/> [accessed 14 April 2020].

Wright, Alison, and Eckart Marchand (eds.), With and Without the Medici: Studies in Tuscan Art and Patronage (Aldershot: Ashgate, 1998).

Zöllner, Frank, ‘Catalogue of Sculptures’, in Michelangelo: Complete Works, ed. by Frank Zöllner, Christof Thoenes and Thomas Pöpper (Cologne: Taschen, 2007), pp. 366-403.