The Rift between Edgar Wind and the Warburg Institute, Seen through the Correspondence between Edgar Wind and Gertrud Bing. A Decisive Chapter in the (mis)Fortune of Warburgian Studies

Monica Centanni
Università Iuav di Venezia
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1425-2968

Volume 2, April 2022

Abstract
This paper analyses the relationship between Edgar Wind and Gertrud Bing through a reading of
their correspondence, in order to shed light on a crucial chapter in the history of studies on
Warburg’s legacy. The rift between Edgar Wind and those representatives of the Warburg Institute
who transferred to London marks a wound in European cultural history that has yet to heal.
Philological research is still needed to reconstruct this history, which is presently characterised by
confusion and gaps. This article should be seen as a first step towards a comprehensive survey of
the Wind–Bing correspondence preserved and filed at the Bodleian Archive in Oxford and the
Warburg Archive in London.

Keywords
Edgar Wind; Gertrud Bing; Aby Warburg; Ernst Gombrich; The Warburg Institute

[pdf]

Bibliography

Barale, Alice, and Laura Squillaro, ed. and trans. by, ‘Regesto di testi inediti e rari dal Warburg Institute Archive sul tema della Fortuna’, La Rivista di Engramma, 92 (August 2011), 66–81.

Bilancioni, Guglielmo, ‘Aby Warburg, the Great Lord of the Labyrinth’, in Aby Warburg and Living Thought, ed. by Monica Centanni (Dueville: Ronzani, 2022), pp. 107–10 (first publ. in il manifesto, 15 January 1984).

Branca, Bernardino, Edgar Wind, filosofo delle immagini. La biografia intellettuale di un discepolo di Aby Warburg (Milan: Mimesis, 2019).

Burkart, Lucas, ‘“Le fantasticherie di alcuni confratelli amanti dell’arte…” Sulla situazione della Biblioteca Warburg per la Scienza della Cultura tra il 1929 e il 1933’, La Rivista di Engramma, 176 (October 2020), 145–98 (first publ. ‘“Die Träumereien einiger kunstliebender Klosterbrüder…”. Zur Situation der Kulturwissenschaftlichen Bibliothek Warburg zwischen 1929 und 1933’, Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte, 63 (2000), 89–119).

Buschendorf, Bernhard, ‘Auf dem Weg nach England – Edgar Wind und die Emigration der Bibliothek Warburg’, in Porträt aus Büchern. Bibliothek Warburg & Warburg Institute. Hamburg – 1933 – London, ed. by Michael Diers (Hamburg: Dölling und Galitz, 1993), pp. 85–128.

Centanni, Monica, ‘“Purtroppo non abbiamo trovato molto tra le carte della nostra cara amica Gertrud Bing che si potrebbe salvare”. Testo e contesti di Ernst Gombrich, Lettera a Delio Cantimori, 20 ottobre 1964’, La Rivista di Engramma, 171 (January/February 2020), 127–53.

Centanni, Monica, ed., Aby Warburg and Living Thought, with essays by Giorgio Pasquali, Mario Praz, Gertrud Bing, Arsenio Frugoni, Guglielmo Bilancioni, Alessandro Dal Lago, Gianni Carchia, Salvatore Settis, Kurt W. Forster, Maurizio Ghelardi (Dueville: Ronzani, 2022).

Centanni, Monica, and Silvia De Laude, ‘Delio Cantimori e il Warburgkreis’, La Rivista di Engramma, 170 (January/February 2020), 113–26.

Centanni, Monica, Fressola, Anna, and Elizabeth Thomson, eds., Mnemosyne Challenged, monographic issue of La Rivista di Engramma, 153 (February 2018).

Centanni, Monica, and Daniela Sacco, ‘Gertrud Bing erede di Warburg’, La Rivista di Engramma, 170 (November 2020), 7–13.

Cieri Via, Claudia, and Micol Forti, eds., Warburg e la cultura italiana. Fra sopravvivenze e prospettive di ricerca (Milan: Mondadori, 2009).

Creighton, Gilbert, ‘Edgar Wind as Man and Thinker’, New Criterion Reader, 3, 2 (October 1984), 36–41. Reprint in Hilton Kramer, ed., New Criterion Reader (New York: Free Press, 1988), pp. 238–43.

de Mille, Agnes, Speak to Me. Dance with Me (New York: Little Brown and Company, 1973).

Despoix, Philippe, and Martin Treml, eds., Gertrud Bing, Fragments sur Aby Warburg (Paris: INHA, 2020).

Di Donato, Riccardo, ‘Dopo Warburg. La “Scienza della cultura” e l’Italia’, in Warburg e la cultura italiana. Fra sopravvivenze e prospettive di ricerca, ed. by Claudia Cieri Via and Micol Forti (Milan: Mondadori, 2009), pp. 149–65.

Engel, Franz, ‘Though this Be Madness: Edgar Wind and the Warburg Tradition’, in Bildakt at the Warburg Institute, ed. by Sabine Marienberg and Jürgen Trabant (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2014), 87–116.

Filisetti, Francesca with Seminario Mnemosyne, ‘“Arianna è scomparsa, il Minotauro è in agguato”. Lettura di Tavola 4 di Mnemosyne Atlas’, La Rivista di Engramma, 163 (March 2019), 243–67.

Ghelardi, Maurizio, ‘Edgar Wind su Aby Warburg: un esercizio ermeneutico’, La Rivista di Engramma, 150 (October 2017), 625–35.

Ghelardi, Maurizio, ‘Edgar Wind, Percy Schramm e il Warburg-Kreis. Sui concetti di Nachleben, Renovatio, Correctio’, La Rivista di Engramma, 176 (October 2020), 13–42.

Gordon, Donald J., ‘In memoriam Gertrud Bing’, In memoriam Gertrud Bing 1892–1964, ed. by Ernst Gombrich (London: The Warburg Institute, 1965), new edition, Italian trans., with a Preface, by Chiara Velicogna, La Rivista di Engramma, 177 (November 2020), 131–66.

Hope, Charles, ‘Naming the Graces. Review of: E. Wind, The Eloquence of Symbols: Studies in Humanist Art, Oxford 1984’, London Review of Books, 6, no. 5 (15 March 1984).

Matthiae, Paolo, ‘Warburg e l’archeologia orientale’, in Warburg e la cultura italiana. Fra sopravvivenze e prospettive di ricerca, ed. by Claudia Cieri Via and Micol Forti (Milan: Mondadori, 2009), pp. 123–38.

Nicastro, Clio, ‘Il Geburtstagsatlas di Ernst H. Gombrich: Tavole A, B, C. Introduzione, testo tedesco e traduzione italiana’, La Rivista di Engramma, 157 (July/August 2018), 25–43.

Nietzsche, Friedrich, The Gay Science [Or. Ed. Die fröhliche Wissenschaft (Chemnitz: Schmeitzner, 1882)], trans. by Thomas Common (Mineola, N.Y.: Dover Publications, 2006).

Panofsky, Erwin, Korrespondenz 1910 bis 1968, ed. by Dieter Wuttke (Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2001–2011).

Pasquali, Giorgio, ‘A Tribute to Aby Warburg’, in Aby Warburg and Living Thought, ed. by Monica Centanni (Dueville: Ronzani, 2022), pp. 37–55 (first publ. in Pegaso II, 4 (1930) 484–95).

Seminario Mnemosyne, coordinated by M. Centanni, A. Fressola, M. Ghelardi, ‘Il Geburtstagsatlas di Ernst H. Gombrich (1937). Indice dei materiali pubblicati in Engramma’, La Rivista di Engramma, 157 (July/August 2018), 11–12.

Settis, Salvatore, ‘Aby Warburg, il demone della forma. Antropologia, storia, memoria’, La Rivista di Engramma, 100 (September/October 2012), 269–87.

Settis, Salvatore, ‘Warburg continuatus. The Description of a Library’, in Aby Warburg and Living Thought, ed. by Monica Centanni (Dueville: Ronzani, 2022), pp. 171–230 (first publ. in Quaderni storici, n. s. 58, a. 20, 1 (April 1985), 5–38).

Settis, Salvatore, and Alessandra Pedersoli, Simone Culotta, ‘Esercizi di confronto tra le Tavole 7, 30, 37 del Geburtstagsatlas di Gombrich e le corrispondenti del Mnemosyne Atlas’, La Rivista di Engramma, 151 (November/December 2017), 91–119.

Takaes de Oliveira, Ianick, ‘“L’esprit de Warburg lui-même sera en paix”. A survey of Edgar Wind’s quarrel with the Warburg Institute’, La Rivista di Engramma, 153 (February 2018), 109–82.

Takaes de Oliveira, Ianick, ‘The Demented, the Demonic, and the Drunkard. Edgar Wind’s Anarchic Art Theory’, La Rivista di Engramma, 176 (October 2020), 43–97.

Thomas, Ben, ‘Edgar Wind. A short Biography’, Stanrzeczy, 1, 8 (2015), 117–37.

Tonin, Thays, ‘I documenti relativi al Geburtstagsatlas di Ernst H. Gombrich. Nota sui materiali conservati al Warburg Institute Archive di Londra’, La Rivista di Engramma, 157 (July/August 2018), 13–23.

Warburg, Aby, and Gertrud Bing, Diario romano, ed. by Maurizio Ghelardi (Turin: Aragno, 2005).

Wind, Edgar, ‘On a Recent Biography of Warburg, Review of: E.H. Gombrich, Aby Warburg: An Intellectual Biography, London 1970’, The Times Literary Supplement, 25 June 1971, pp. 735–36.

Wind, Edgar, ‘On a Recent Biography of Warburg, Review of: E.H. Gombrich, Aby Warburg: An Intellectual Biography, London 1970. First digital ed., La Rivista di Engramma, 153 (febbraio 2018), pp. 183-195.

Wittkower, Margot, and Teresa Barnett, Partnership and Discovery: Margot and Rudolf Wittkower. Margot Wittkower Interviewed by Teresa Barnett (Los Angeles: The J. Paul Getty Trust, 1994).

Wuttke, Dieter, Kosmopolis der Wissenschaft. E. R. Curtius und das Warburg Institute. Briefe 1928 bis 1954 und andere Dokumente (Baden-Baden: Valentin Koerner, 1989).